🔗 Share this article

The Australian batsman evenly coats butter on the top and bottom of a slice of white bread. “That’s the key,” he explains as he brings down the lid of his toastie maker. “There you go. Then you get it golden on each side.” He lifts the lid to reveal a perfectly browned of delicious perfection, the bubbling cheese happily bubbling away. “Here’s the secret method,” he announces. At which point, he does something unexpected and strange.

Already, I sense a layer of boredom is beginning to cover your eyes. The warning signs of overly fancy prose are going off. You’re likely conscious that Labuschagne hit 160 for his state team this week and is being widely discussed for an national team comeback before the Ashes.

No doubt you’d prefer to read more about that. But first – you now understand with frustration – you’re going to have to get through three paragraphs of light-hearted musing about grilled cheese, plus an additional unnecessary part of overly analytical commentary in the direct address. You sigh again.

Labuschagne flips the sandwich on to a dish and heads over the fridge. “It’s uncommon,” he announces, “but I personally prefer the cold toastie. There, in the fridge. You let the cheese firm up, go bat, come back. Alright. Sandwich is perfect.”

The Cricket Context

Alright, let’s try it like this. Shall we get the sports aspect to begin with? Small reward for your patience. And while there may still be six weeks until the initial match, Labuschagne’s 100 runs against Tasmania – his third in recent months in various games – feels significantly impactful.

This is an Australian top order seriously lacking performance and method, exposed by the South African team in the WTC final, shown up once more in the West Indies after that. Labuschagne was dropped during that series, but on one hand you sensed Australia were desperate to rehabilitate him at the earliest chance. Now he looks to have given them the right opportunity.

This represents a plan that Australia need to work. Usman Khawaja has just one 100 in his past 44 innings. The young batsman looks not quite a Test match opener and rather like the handsome actor who might play a Test opener in a Indian film. None of the alternatives has presented a strong argument. Nathan McSweeney looks cooked. Marcus Harris is still inexplicably hanging around, like dust or mold. Meanwhile their leader, the pace bowler, is hurt and suddenly this feels like a unusually thin squad, lacking command or stability, the kind of natural confidence that has often put Australia 2-0 up before a ball is bowled.

Labuschagne’s Return

Here comes Labuschagne: a top-ranked Test batsman as just two years ago, just left out from the one-day team, the right person to return structure to a fragile lineup. And we are told this is a composed and reflective Labuschagne these days: a streamlined, back-to-basics Labuschagne, less intensely fixated with minor adjustments. “It seems I’ve really stripped it back,” he said after his ton. “Not overthinking, just what I should make runs.”

Of course, nobody truly believes this. Probably this is a rebrand that exists just in Labuschagne’s own head: still endlessly adjusting that approach from morning to night, going further toward simplicity than any player has attempted. Like basic approach? Marnus will take time in the nets with advisors and replays, exhaustively remoulding himself into the most basic batsman that has ever existed. This is just the trait of the obsessed, and the characteristic that has consistently made Labuschagne one of the most wildly absorbing sportsmen in the game.

The Broader Picture

Maybe before this very open historic rivalry, there is even a type of pleasing dissonance to Labuschagne’s unquenchable obsession. In England we have a side for whom detailed examination, let alone self-analysis, is a risky subject. Go with instinct. Stay in the moment. Embrace the current.

In the other corner you have a player such as Labuschagne, a player terminally obsessed with cricket and totally indifferent by public perception, who observes cricket even in the moments outside play, who treats this absurd sport with exactly the level of odd devotion it requires.

His method paid off. During his intense period – from the instant he appeared to replace a concussed the senior batsman at Lord’s in 2019 to through 2022 – Labuschagne was able to see the game with greater insight. To reach it – through pure determination – on a higher, weirder, more frenzied level. During his time with English county cricket, colleagues noticed him on the game day positioned on a seat in a focused mindset, mentally rehearsing each delivery of his time at the crease. As per the analytics firm, during the first few years of his career a unusually large catches were dropped off his bat. Remarkably Labuschagne had predicted events before anyone had a chance to influence it.

Recent Challenges

Maybe this was why his performance dipped the moment he reached the summit. There were no new heights to imagine, just a boundless, uncharted void before his eyes. Additionally – he began doubting his favorite stroke, got trapped on the crease and seemed to lose awareness of his stumps. But it’s all the same thing. Meanwhile his coach, his coach, reckons a attention to shorter formats started to weaken assurance in his alignment. Good news: he’s recently omitted from the 50-over squad.

Surely it matters, too, that Labuschagne is a man of deep religious faith, an evangelical Christian who thinks that this is all predetermined, who thus sees his task as one of achieving this peak performance, despite being puzzling it may look to the ordinary people.

This approach, to my mind, has always been the key distinction between him and Smith, a inherently talented player